Activism and Advocacy with Data-driven Narratives



Activism and Advocacy with Data-driven Narratives

0 1


activism-and-advocacy-with-data-driven-narratives

Slides for a Columbia SIPA class

On Github abelsonlive / activism-and-advocacy-with-data-driven-narratives

Data for Communication and Impact

Brian Abelson | @brianabelson | brianabelson@gmail.com

Senior Data Scientist, Enigma

Fellow, Tow Center

slides: bit.ly/1JI2zA1

Why Data-driven Narratives?

  • Data enables the exploration of relationships, trends, and anecodotes you might not otherwise have access to or might be hard to clearly communicate.
  • Data is varnished with the veneer of "truth".
  • Data-driven narratives have the potential to place the audience in the story.

Why not Data-driven Narratives?

  • Data fetishism can distract from the human-elements of a story.
  • Data is varnished with the veneer of "truth".
  • Data can be misleading or hard to interpret (even for the author).

The Good

A good data narrative has the same principles of a good piece of writing.
  • Clearly communicates the central point.
  • Makes a creative and compelling argument.
  • Responsibly qualifies or complicates its claims.
  • Provides avenues for future exploration.

The Bad

Good data narratives are all alike;

every bad data narrative is bad in its own way.

The Ugly

Don't Do This:

Tufte's 10 rules

Show your Data Use Graphics Avoid ChartJunk Utilize Data-ink Use Labels Utilize Micro/Macro Seperate Layers Use Multiples Utilize Color Understand Narrative

Russian Troops in Ukraine - BuzzFeed

Speeding Cops - Sun Sentinel

Drought's Footprint - New York Times

What is a "NewsApp"?

  • A large, web-based interactive database that tells a journalistic story using software instead of word and pictures.
  • An tool for placing your audience inside a story.
  • A utility for for generating new stories.
  • A "Good" Dashboard

The "Near and Far" of NewsApps

Scott Klein, ProPublica "what I like to see in a news application [is] a way to see the 'far' view (in other words, the big national picture) and the 'near' view (how the big national phenomenon relates to me personally)"

Dollars for Docs - ProPublica

Syrian Refugees - Al Jazeera America

U.S. Daily Temperature Anomalies - Enigma

U.S. Daily Temperature Anomalies - Enigma

U.S. Daily Temperature Anomalies - Enigma

U.S. Daily Temperature Anomalies - Enigma

What do you think? Gun Permits Map

What do you think? Twitter Maps

Creating an Impact Workflow - NewsLynx

Thanks!

Brian Abelson | @brianabelson | brianabelson@gmail.com